How Do Pip & Estella Change in Great Expectations? | Great Expectations | Drama Channel
and find homework help for other Literature questions at eNotes. 1 educator answer; Discuss the Pip-Estella relationship in Great Expectations. What bearing . It begins as one cruelly manipulated by Estella. Her beauty and social poise attract Pip immediately and, egged on by Miss Havisham, she uses. Ross H. Dabney puts a different spin on Pip's relationship with Estella; Pip "is Pip, both in his dream of having great expectations to win Estella and in the.
With them, Dickens extends his satire of society from the abuse of children and criminals to the corruption of wealth. Miss Havisham's fawning, self-interested, envious relatives and their competition for her wealth illustrate the evil effects of the love of money. Dickens sees the valuing of money and status over all else as a primary drive in society, which is dominated by the mercantile middle class.
Miss Havisham and her decayed house have another relationship; it parallels the diseased state of her mind. By stopping time, symbolized by the clocks all reading twenty to nine, Miss Havisham has stopped her life, which thereby becomes death-in-life.
By wilfully stopping her life at a moment of pain and humiliation, she indulges her own anger, self-pity, and desire for revenge; she imagines her death as "the finished curse" upon the man who jilted her page In her revenge, which destroys her life, she is like a child who hurts itself in its anger at someone else. The decay around her also represents her relationship with others. Her relationships are symbiotic, as we discussed in class.
Her relatives try to feed off her wealth, and she feeds off their envy and subservience. The feeding relationship is symbolized by the mice, which eat the bridal cake and which she claims have gnawed at her heart. She even imagines herself laid out on the table for their consumption after her death.
Miss Havisham feeds off both Estella and Pip to achieve her own ends. The feeding or attempting to feed off of others for self-gratification is one manifestation of the dehumanization or depersonalization that runs through the novel; repeatedly characters use others as objects, to enhance their own prestige and self-image, like Pumblechook constantly taking credit and Mrs.
Joe raising Pip "by hand. Pip calls Pumblechook "that basest of swindlers"; taking credit for events to which he has no connection, he takes Pip "into custody, with a right of patronage that left all his former criminality far behind" page Because of its dehumanizing emphasis on wealth and status, society itself is implicitly accused of criminality.
As the cruelties and destructive consequences of society's values reveal themselves, society is condemned as criminal. Estella complies, and they play a card game, Beggar My Neighbor. Later, Miss Havisham explicitly urges Pip to love Estella: If she favours you, love her. If she wounds you, love her.
If she tears your heart to pieces—and as it gets older and stronger—it will tear deeper—love her, love her, love her!
I adopted her to be loved.
How Do Pip & Estella Change in Great Expectations?
I bred her and educated her to be loved. I developed her into what she is, that she might be loved. It is blind devotion, unquestioning self-humiliation, utter submission, trust and belief against yourself and against the whole world, giving up your whole heart and soul to the smiter—as I did!
What kind of love is she describing if the feelings she describes are indeed love?
Do Pip's feelings for Estella and his relationship to her resemble the "love" Miss Havisham describes? Is he, like Miss Havisham, obsessed by his "love"? Would it be imposing a modern concept onto Pip to say that he is addicted to love?
Great Expectations: The strange romance of Pip and Estella
Though Pip is aware that the love she refers to sounds like hate, despair, revenge, and death, a curse rather than a blessing, he perseveres in his attachment for Estella.
Although both women differ tremendously as to their social status and personal history, they have one thing in common: With these two mothers Estella appears to be destined of becoming a similarly cruel woman. The little girl is thus brought up in a dark and dingy place, where everything seems to rot away, and where there is no room for anything but melancholy and contempt for the outside world. Growing up in such cold and hostile surroundings has made Estella into what she is.
Shortly before she dies Miss Havisham confesses: In this cruel scheme Pip is a mere guinea pig for Estella to practice her heart-breaking skills on.
In this sense, the beautiful girl is raised to be just as cold and unattainable as the sparkling but ever distant star in the nocturnal sky: She seemed much older than I, of course, being a girl and beautiful and self-possessed; and she was as scornful of me as if she had been one-and-twenty, and a queen. There was no discrepancy of years between us, to remove her far from me; we were of nearly the same age […]; but the air of inaccessibility which her beauty and her manner gave her, tormented me in the midst of my delight […] Wretched boy!
The Relationship Between Pip, Jaggers and Estella Great Expectations
She is thousands of miles away from me. I adopted her to be loved.
I bred her and educated her to be loved. I developed her into what she is, that she might be loved.